Neil MacGruder

"I already gave you my statement! Do the work! Go by proper procedure!"

Judge Neil MacGruder was a traumatized, dissociative-identity-disorder-inflicted serial killer, vigilante, and "Injustice Collector" committing murders under an unidentified alternate personality who appeared in Power Corrupts in Profiler.

Modus Operandi
MacGruder targeted people connected to his son's case he held responsible for his death. He incapacitated them with blows to the head with blank trophies left at the crime scene, undressed them, and killed them in various ways associated with cleaning, including drowning and shoving bar soap in the mouth, scrubbing with a wire brush to the point of fatal bleeding, and pouring chlorine bleach down the throat. Other signatures included leaving the victims facing mirrors or other reflective surfaces as well as folding their clothes and leaving them at the scenes. Due to MacGruder's tendency to cut imself, his blood also dripped at the crime scenes and was left behind without any cleaning up.

Known Victims

 * Franklin Garrity (drowned in his business headquarters' fountain; shoved a bar of soap in his mouth and positioned him facing the glass front door postmortem
 * Michelle Bryan (shoved her face into a hotel room sink and scrubbed with a wire brush until she fatally bled out; wrapped in a towel and positioned facing the room mirror postmortem)
 * Nick Dorey (forced chlorine bleach down his throat; left him in is bed facing a cracked mirror placed on the ceiling above him postmortem)
 * James Henegar (attempted; was shot by him instead)